Eye Makeup Removers

One of my favorite things to do is try a variety of products and then compare them to each other to pick my favorite.  I'm that girl that actually buys the products from the road tests that Real Simple magazine does.  The last review of products I posted was mascaras I've tried, and someone asked if I would post about eye makeup removers.  I haven't tried a ton, but I do have some favorites.

Aveeno Positively Radiant Makeup Removing Cleanser 

check Aveeno for stores

I love Aveeno products because they always smell so good!

This cleanser did not remove a trace of my eye makeup, though;

I ended up using it just like a facial cleanser.  Thumbs down

on the makeup removing part.

Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover 

$6.49 at Target

I found myself having to use a LOT of this to get

all the traces of my mascara off.  Also, it says it's

oil-free but I found it actually left an oily

residue around my eyes.  Definitely not a favorite.

Yes to Carrots Makeup Removing Cleanser

$9.99 at Target

This does a good job of taking all of the

eye makeup off, but it takes a little scrubbing

in order to do so.  I use this when I'm not in a hurry,

and I like it because it's paraben-free.

Mary Kay Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

$15.00 at Mary Kay

This is my favorite liquid eye makeup remover.

I don't have to put a lot on a cotton ball, and it takes

off even waterproof mascara.  It's not oily

and because I feel like it lasts a long time,

I think it's worth the money.

Neutrogena Make-Up Remover Cleansing Towelettes

$4.49 at Target

These are hands-down my favorite of all.

They are gentler than a cotton ball, and they 

remove every bit of makeup.  If I'm in a hurry

this is definitely what I grab, and I also

like being able to have them in 

my purse or carry-on if I am traveling.

I've also tried the Target brand eye makeup remover and hated it; I felt like I was using half the bottle just to get my mascara to come off.  I don't think they sell that anymore because now it's the up&up brand.  Has anyone tried that?

What makeup removers do you use?  I would love to know what you recommend!